What do you need the camera to show?
What do you want to see? You might need to identify someone ringing the doorbell, check what happened outside your door or keep a record of a particular entrance. Each calls for different settings. A camera set to record everything in view may collect more personal data than you need.
If people can be identified in the footage, the camera is processing personal data. The Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner (FDPIC) explains that surveillance must be justified, proportionate and transparent. The Commissioner also asks people to consider less intrusive measures, such as reinforcing a door or installing an alarm.
Write down what you need the system to do, then consider whether you need an image at all. Our comparison of cameras and alarms explains the difference between seeing what happened, detecting an incident and having someone respond to an alert. Another device may meet the need more simply than several cameras.
Keep the camera view within your property
As a general rule, private individuals may not monitor public spaces. The FDPIC explains the limited exceptions, for example where a lawful camera on private property cannot avoid capturing a small part of a public area. Previous damage to your home does not entitle you to film the whole street.
The FDPIC distinguishes a video intercom that activates when someone presses the doorbell and shows only the caller from a camera that monitors a public space. If a video doorbell records a wider area continuously, assess what it actually does when deciding whether its use is lawful.
Fictional example. An installer proposes a camera above a garage to show visitors arriving. The image also shows the pavement and the neighbour’s window. Before the camera is fixed in place, the owner asks the installer to change the angle and play back a recording to check that the privacy mask conceals the window. This lets the owner check the result promised in the quote.
Neighbours and shared areas
The FDPIC calls for prior consultation with those affected when other people use the area to be filmed, such as a laundry room, shared garage or passageway. Their interests count when deciding whether monitoring is proportionate.
Sending a letter does not in itself authorise an installation. You still need to check the proposed coverage, who has rights over the shared space and which decisions are for the landlord or the co-owners. Involve neighbours while the plans can still change.
For a flat, describe which area the camera would cover, how it would operate and who would have access to the images. Give this information to the managing agent or the co-owners’ association before fitting equipment in a shared area. Our guide to securing a flat also covers individual doors and shared entrances.
How long to keep footage and who may see it
The FDPIC’s guidance says to keep images only as long as necessary, generally 24 hours. Tell people they will be filmed before they enter the camera’s field of view, for example with a clearly visible sign. Identify the person responsible if this is not already clear. Restrict access to the footage.
Check the retention period suggested by the app before accepting it. Ask how recordings are deleted, who can change the setting and what happens to a clip saved after an incident. Spare storage space does not in itself justify keeping images for longer.
Check the microphone settings, user accounts, where footage is stored and what access the provider has. Record the actual settings in the handover documents. If people share an account, it is harder to tell who still has access when someone leaves or you change provider.
What to ask the installer to demonstrate
Use this table at handover to check how the equipment and service work. A legal assessment of your particular installation is a separate matter.
On a small screen, scroll the table horizontally.
| What to check | What to ask the installer to show you |
|---|---|
| Field of view | Day and night footage, property boundaries and masked areas |
| Activation | The difference between live viewing, recording on an event and continuous recording |
| Sound | Whether there is a microphone and whether it is switched on |
| Retention | How long footage is kept, how it is deleted and how a clip is handled |
| Access | Who can sign in, what the provider can see and how to remove a user |
| Notice | Where the sign is displayed and how to contact the person responsible |
Check a recording as well as the installer’s live preview. Ask where to find these settings again after an update or replacement. For connected features, check what happens if mains power or the internet fails.
How to give footage of an offence to the authorities
The FDPIC says footage of an offence should go to the competent authorities. Publishing people’s faces to identify a suspect yourself raises legal concerns. A judge decides whether the footage is admissible as evidence. Recording an incident is no guarantee that anyone can be identified or that the footage will be accepted in court. See the guidance on private video surveillance.
Keep the incident reference and ask the police how to give them the relevant clip. Avoid making unnecessary copies or sharing it in private groups or on social media. Our guide to what to do after a burglary in Switzerland covers the other steps.
If a neighbour’s camera records you
Start by asking what the camera actually records. You can exercise your right of access by asking the operator about images of you. Depending on the circumstances, you can ask for images to be deleted or the camera angle to be changed. The FDPIC explains what to do if a neighbour’s camera films you.
Keep a record of your correspondence and explain the problem precisely. Perhaps the camera records your daily movements, looks into a room or operates without a visible notice. A discussion about the actual field of view may be enough to resolve the issue. If you still disagree, seek advice on your next steps. Even where certain court fees do not apply in data protection cases, you may still have to pay a lawyer.
You do not need advance permission from the FDPIC to monitor your own property. Before installation, check any building rules, lease terms and co-ownership requirements that apply.
Sources and references
These are the documents used in this guide.
- FDPIC guidance on private video surveillance The principles of justification, proportionality and transparency.
- FDPIC guidance on filming public spaces The limited circumstances in which a private camera may capture part of a public space.
- FDPIC guidance on cameras in the neighbourhood What to do if a neighbour’s camera records you.