Free advice or a paid independent assessment?
An initial inspection of your home may be free. Depending on where you live, the police may offer a prevention visit. An installer may also visit to prepare a quote. For an independent assessment, ask how much the report, plans and consultation with contractors will cost.
When a home security assessment is useful
Even a well-equipped home may leave gaps in protection. An alarm you set only when you go on holiday serves a different purpose from detectors you can leave on while you sleep. Replacing the main lock also leaves other entry points to consider. An assessment brings these questions together before you spend money.
Ask what a provider means by a ‘survey’, ‘audit’ or ‘security visit’. It could mean verbal advice, an inspection, tests agreed in advance, a written report or help overseeing the work. Get a clear description, particularly if several companies will carry out the work.
An assessment can help when you move in, plan renovations, change your routine or lose track of what an older system covers. After an attempted break-in, deal with the immediate practical steps and make the premises safe first. If someone has made a specific threat, contact the police. A building assessment cannot deal with the threat itself.
How the home is used when people are in
If your concern is a home invasion, tell the assessor from the outset that you want protection while people are at home. Explain who moves around at night, returns late or visits to provide care, and whether you have pets. These details help you choose measures that work for everyone.
Worked example. A household asks for a new alarm because the existing system stays off every night. Before recommending a replacement, the assessor asks why nobody sets it and checks which functions are available. The visit should help distinguish between a change of routine, a setting that needs checking and an alteration to the equipment.
Compare the three approaches
Police prevention advice, an installer’s visit and an independent assessment can complement one another. A free visit can be thorough, and an independent assessor can have a limited brief. Check what each visit covers and how the provider will explain their recommendations.
On a small screen, scroll the table horizontally.
| What to compare | Police advice | Installer’s visit | Independent assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Get prevention advice suited to your home | Design a solution and quote for the work | Assess the home and propose a plan within an agreed brief |
| Cost | Often free; check the conditions in your country. | Ask before booking whether there is a charge | Fees and expenses agreed in advance |
| What you receive | Verbal advice or documents, depending on the scheme | A quote, specifications and details of the services offered | A report, priorities and any cost estimates agreed in the contract |
| What to check | Eligibility and level of support | Scope of the visit and range of products sold | Commercial ties, qualifications and work excluded from the brief |
Police advice
In several countries, the police offer home security advice, often free of charge. The service, its conditions and how to request it depend on the country. See the page for your country.
An installer’s visit
A locksmith, joiner or alarm installer may visit to prepare a quote. Their experience can help establish what is feasible in their trade. Check whether the visit covers a particular entry point, one system or the household’s overall security needs.
Ask how the proposal addresses the problem you have identified and what the installer will leave to others. If the company recommends a product it sells, ask about its limitations and compare the price with other offers for the same work.
An independent assessment
An assessment commissioned separately from equipment sales can help if the project involves several trades or will run in stages. Agree which tasks are included. Identifying needs, comparing options, setting priorities, seeking quotes and overseeing the work may all be separate services.
Ask whether the consultant has ties to suppliers or receives commission. Find out if another company could work from the report. This helps you judge the value of the advice independently of any brand recommendation.
What happens during the visit?
A full visit should allow time to discuss your needs, inspect the property and talk through the findings. The number of minutes spent or items checked tells you little about the quality of the assessment on its own.
Start with your routines and concerns
Explain what prompted the visit. You might have trouble locking a door, rarely use the alarm, have someone new living with you or be planning building work. Mention constraints such as limited mobility, a tenancy or alterations needing co-owners’ consent.
Ask the assessor to put your objective into words before discussing equipment. ‘Wake us if a door opens at night’ tells them more than ‘we want a good alarm’. They can then assess how to meet that need in your home.
Check the entry points and how the systems work together
Walk through the areas agreed in the brief, including any side entrances and outbuildings in scope. Ask the assessor to distinguish between visual observations and tests, and to record anything they could not access. Looking at the outside of a door does not test how well it resists forced entry.
For an existing alarm, agree which uses the visit will cover, which manuals are available and whether testing is included. Arrange any test alert with the installer or assessor and, where relevant, the monitoring provider. Establish who receives the alert and what happens next.
Leave with a clear order of priorities
Allow time at the end of the visit to go through the findings. Identify what you can do straight away, what needs further investigation and what work needs a quote. If a recommendation would be difficult to follow every day, say so before the assessor finishes the report.
What should be included in the report?
Each recommendation should relate to something the assessor found. A phrase such as ‘improve security’ gives an installer too little to quote on and leaves you no way to check the result. Ask what the measure should achieve, what limits were identified and what to do next.
The summary should identify the property, the household routines considered, the date of the visit and anything excluded. Keep photographs and survey records to what the assessment requires and treat them as confidential. The report can then separate changes to routines, work on existing equipment and proposed new equipment.
For each action, use the same headings: finding, objective, priority, specialist to consult and check required. If the assessor gives a cost, check whether it covers equipment only, installation, other work, taxes and any subscription. You will still need a quote from the company carrying out the work.
Some work calls for a specialist. For example, changes to a door or its reinforcement, new partitions or a refuge area must take account of escape routes, accessibility and the building itself. The report should identify which checks are still needed before a proposal can become a detailed design.
If you need a refuge area, ask for a feasibility study of the room and how it fits into the building. Then weigh that option against the other priorities for your home.
Preparing for the visit and protecting your privacy
Gather any manuals, model numbers and relevant contracts you have. Prepare your questions and explain how the household uses the home. You do not need a detailed inventory of valuables just to make an appointment.
A short note can cover:
- The entry points and equipment you want checked
- Situations where current measures fall short or are hard to use
- Any constraints affecting the property or its occupants
- Work already planned, your approximate budget and the documents you expect to receive
Check the visitor’s identity and confirm the appointment with the organisation or company you contacted. Before sharing documents or agreeing to photos, ask why they are needed, who will see them and how long they will be kept. Leave alarm codes, detailed plans and the location of valuables out of general enquiry forms and initial emails.
You can show documents during the visit without leaving copies of everything. If technical information must be shared, agree how to send it securely. Discuss confidentiality when arranging the service.
How to compare fees and choose an assessor
Judge a private assessor’s fee against the work you are commissioning. Verbal advice during a visit, a detailed report and support through to handover require different amounts of work. A price range is of little use unless the scope, country, travel costs and documents supplied are comparable.
Ask for the total fee for the initial assessment, the price of any options and the circumstances in which the assessor would charge extra. For the proposed work, distinguish a contractor’s quote from an estimate or a rough budget. Check whether a meeting to discuss the report is included.
Ask for references from similar assignments and an anonymised sample report. Experience with one system does not establish expertise in every trade. A good assessor can explain the limits of their work and when you need a building, alarm or other specialist.
Check that the assessor’s professional insurance covers the work. Ask the relevant authority whether this activity requires a permit where you live. Be wary of anyone who promises a break-in-proof home, pressures you to buy immediately or refuses to say what you will receive.
Getting quotes and checking the work at handover
Use the recommendations to request several quotes for the same work. Compare equipment, installation, ancillary work, maintenance and recurring services separately. Our guide to home security measures explains how physical barriers, detection and alert transmission work together.
At handover, ask the installer to explain and demonstrate how to use the system with the people who will use it. For an alarm, check how it works when people are at home. Everyone should know which areas remain monitored, where they can move freely and what to do if the alarm goes off. Agree the tests with the installer and, where applicable, the monitoring provider.
Keep the manuals, model references, installation records and contact details. List equipment still to be fitted and features still to be activated. Ask for written confirmation when outstanding work is complete.
The report describes the home at the time of the visit. A move, an extension or a change in who lives there may mean some conclusions need revisiting. To get started, walk through your home with the home security checklist, then take your questions to your local police prevention service or the professional you have chosen.
Sources and references
For sources on free police advice, see the country pages linked above.
Review your own home
Use the checklist to review entry points, household routines and who to contact.
Open the security checklist