Compare quotes for the whole installation
Wiring alone does not determine the price. In a renovation, routing cables and making good afterwards can cost more than the difference in price between detectors. In a new build, cable runs can be laid during construction. Ask for both quotes to cover the same number of zones, the same backup communications link and the same tests.
How the building affects your choice
In a new build or major renovation, you can plan cable routes before the walls are finished. Consider a wired alarm at this stage and leave space for future equipment. Agree the positions with the other trades working on the building.
In an occupied home, wireless equipment avoids many cable runs. It still needs fixings, power for the control panel and a survey of signal range. Test the signal through the actual walls and floors and out to any outbuildings you want to protect.
A hybrid system can keep existing cables and add wireless detectors where running a new cable would mean too much work. Check that the detectors are compatible with the panel and ask how it checks that they are still working.
How detectors connect and how alerts reach you
‘Wireless’ often describes the link from the detectors to the control panel. It says nothing about how the panel contacts you or a monitoring centre. A wired alarm can send alerts over a mobile network, and a wireless alarm can rely on a fixed internet connection.
Ask for two simple diagrams. One should show how the detectors communicate with the panel, the other how the panel sends an alert outside the home. A wired system may still need a network connection, and fitting a SIM card will not keep the equipment powered.
Which faults will you hear about?
A cable removes the need for a radio signal between the devices it connects, but it can be cut or develop a fault. Wireless links need adequate coverage and a way to handle interference. Either system should report faults that affect its operation.
The system can check whether its devices are communicating and working as expected. Ask which faults it detects, who receives the reports and how long they take to arrive. Simply setting off the alarm will not answer these questions.
The equipment and the standard it claims to meet determine how it detects jamming and what settings it needs. An alarm may report interference without being able to prevent it. If a supplier calls a system ‘jam-proof’, ask what happens during interference and which communications links will still work.
The guide to alarms during power cuts and internet outages explains what to check at each stage, from the control panel, its peripherals and the router to the mobile link and the receiving centre.
Both types need maintenance
Wireless detectors often run on batteries. Battery life depends on the model and how it is used. The quote should say who replaces batteries, what it costs and who handles low-battery warnings. A laboratory maximum cannot tell you when each battery in your home will need replacing.
A wired system also has power supplies and backup batteries, sometimes in several devices. List the components that need servicing and ask how long the chosen configuration is documented to run on backup power.
Luxembourg’s Grand Ducal Police offer guidance on fitting an alarm in a new build or an existing home. Ask the installer to assess what is practical in your property and what maintenance the system will need.
Compare the same features in both quotes
On a small screen, scroll the table horizontally.
| Criterion | What to compare |
|---|---|
| Coverage area | The same access points and monitored areas |
| Installation work | Cables, trunking, making good, fixings and power supply |
| Faults | Loss of contact with a detector, a power cut or a failed transmission link |
| Maintenance | Batteries, backup batteries, call-out charges and labour |
| Future expansion | Compatible detectors, spare capacity and availability of parts |
| Services provided | App, alarm monitoring and features that still work after cancellation |
Fictional example. The cables at a house’s main entrances are in good condition, but a new extension has no alarm wiring. Get a quote for a hybrid system before replacing all the cabling or opening up newly finished walls. Check the condition of the cables and which equipment they work with before deciding.
What to test before handover
Ask the installer to test each zone, check that alerts get through and explain how faults are reported. For wireless detectors, check signal quality in their final positions with doors and rooms in normal use. For a wired installation, ask for a circuit plan and the results of the corresponding tests.
Choose a quote that meets your needs and makes the installation work and maintenance clear. Use the home alarm guide to decide which functions you need, then choose the type of connection that suits them.
Sources and references
These are the documents used in this guide.
- Advice from Luxembourg’s Grand Ducal Police Public source. Consult the original for its date, scope and conditions of use.